Skip to main content

After the Holidays: How to Turn Q4 Gifters and Recipients into Year-Round Gifting Customers

Strategies that turn your gifting channel into a year-round habit for gifters and recipients with these strategies.

Once the holiday dust (or is that just sugar cookie crumbs?) settles, it’s already time to look ahead to the next year — and we mean the whole year, not just next Q4.

By the end of this year’s gifting wave, you’ll have amassed a ton of data points with Zest. You’ll learn things like who gifted what, when they gifted, and how they gifted (and don’t forget that you’ll learn just as much about gift recipients, too!).

You’ll end this year with a firmer grasp on your gifting audience as a whole, which is exactly what you need to grow this channel throughout the year ahead.

In this playbook, we lay out steps you can take to keep recent Q4 gifters engaged and gifting, entice gift recipients to send a gift of their own (or even shop for themselves), and create more gifting opportunities outside of Q4.

The goal is to create a sustainable strategy to market your gifting channel and make this lucrative program hum steadily along.

Keep reading to learn how to:

How to Turn One-time Gifters into Repeat Customers

When it comes to growing your gifting channel, start with the DTC strategies you already know. The same strategies you use to boost sales and repeat purchases for your DTC store are, at their core, the same ones you should lean into to stoke more gifting all year long.

Your goal is (basically) the same: Turn a one-time gifter into a repeat gifter (and, eventually, a gifting evangelist).

In order to smash that goal, you need to reframe how gifting is thought of. You have to shift gifting from a seasonal purchase to a year-round habit.

How? Relentlessly reminding your customers about all of the giftable moments they're overlooking in Q1 through Q3.

Year-round giftable moments worth reminders

The holidays happening throughout Q4 are forever going to fuel your brand’s peak gifting season.

However, especially in the corporate world, gifting is a year-round need (even if your Q4 gifters don’t know it yet). Here are some of the leading moments to remind gifters of throughout the calendar year:

  • Company milestones
    Smashing sales quotas, hitting ARR goals, or landing a white whale account are all occasions we see companies celebrate all year long.
    ​

  • Client and customer relationships
    ​
    From account-based marketing (ABM) campaigns to client appreciation to general surprise-and-delight moments, gifts are a fool-proof way for companies to garner attention and genuinely positive sentiment.
    ​

  • Employee anniversaries and retirements
    ​
    Whether it’s someone’s first year or fiftieth in the books, these gifts are increasingly vital to employee retention and talent attraction.
    ​

  • New-hire welcome kits
    ​
    On the other end of the spectrum, new hire welcome gifts are basically an expectation in today’s workforce. They foster goodwill and start an employee’s tenure on a positive note.
    ​


    ​

  • Birthdays, bereavement, weddings, etc.
    ​
    A token of care, celebration, or sympathy at key life events shows a company’s human side, fostering good vibes between the gifter and the giftee.

The challenge? You don’t know when all of these events are happening for your gifters.

Unlike Christmas, for example, where you know exactly when it’s happening and can plan a calculated marketing campaign leading up to it, the aforementioned events happen at irregular intervals and sporadic times.

So while you may not be able to point your finger at a specific date for many of these moments, there are tactics you can implement to stay top of mind.

Pssst! This doesn't mean to abandon the fixed calendar events you can plan for, like Employee Appreciation Day (first Friday in March), Administrative Professionals Day (April), fiscal year-end, back-to-school, and more. The goal here is to get past gifters to think about gifting as a part of everyday life, not just an act bound to fixed holidays.

Building gifting's top-of-mind awareness muscle

The odds of reaching out to a gifter at every exact moment they need a gift for one of these occasions are slim. To combat the unknown gifting dates, it’s vital to consistently communicate your gift channel’s offerings so your brand becomes synonymous with easy gifting at any time, not just calendar holidays.

Tenets that fortify your top-of-mind awareness (TOMA):

  • Keep messaging and value props consistent from your website to your email comms. You might think you’re just repeating yourself (ugh, annoying), but that repetition pays off.

  • Offer real value in the emails you send to gifters. This could look like feature updates, new gifts, gifting research, etc. Anything that helps them make a decision is always a good idea.
    ​

  • Make your messaging human and you’ll resonate more deeply. Gifting is inherently emotional, so don’t shy away from getting all mushy gushy and sharing heartfelt stories about real gifting experiences.
    ​

  • Add social proof to your comms whenever you can. A simple testimonial about the power of a great gift is often enough to inspire someone to gift again. After all, who doesn’t love making others feel awesome?

When to get in touch with gifters

Not sure when to reach out to gifters when there isn't a fixed holiday coming up? Your comms timing outside of Q4 is less about hitting a big holiday and more about finding a cadence that fits your brand and audience. Like the rest of your marketing strategies, you don't want to send emails every day and become annoying (and blocked), but you do want to be persistent and recallable by gifters any time they need a present.

  • Email past gifters quarterly (at minimum).
    ​
    Set up an automated drip campaign to send to your list of gifters at the top of each quarter. This casual gifting check-in may be just what they need to remember the fresh batch of incoming new hires or the quarterly all-hands meeting where they’re going to celebrate an ARR milestone.
    ​

  • Show appreciation after someone sends a gift.
    ​
    Someone trusted your product enough to share it with others and make a good impression. That’s a pretty big vote of confidence in your brand, so it seems only fair to show gratitude when people choose your store for gifting.
    ​
    A gesture of appreciation can look like a simple thank you, early access to limited-edition gifts, or even a discount.
    ​
    Check out these emails sent to gifters after their purchase 👇
    ​


    ​

    ​

  • Share gift guides specific to giftable moments.
    ​
    One of the best ways to stay top of mind is to offer genuinely useful information. Picking out a present for a specific occasion can throw gifters into decision fatigue, so they often default to the ho-hum Amazon gift card.
    ​
    Get ahead of the analysis paralysis with gift guides highlighting new products, popular gifts, good deals, and curated bundles that make picking out a gift painless.
    ​

  • Add a gifting blurb to every email you send.
    ​
    Since you never know when the gifting need is going to strike, we recommend adding a gifting blurb or CTA to every email you send. Talking about your gifting storefront consistently bakes your brand into their subconscious as the go-to place for gifts.
    ​

    This simple mention of gifting with direct links to the corporate gifting landing page lives at the bottom of Brightland's emails.

Heads up! This is also one of those moments where you can include a gifting blurb in emails to everyone, whether they’ve gifted before or not. Your typical consumer may very well be a potential gifter, so don’t hesitate to spread the word among the gen pop, too!

  • Educate your audience about the impact of gifting.
    ​
    Many people think sending a gift once a year during the Q4 holidays is “good enough.” Why? They simply don’t know the immensely positive impact gifting can have all year long.
    ​
    While you encourage people to send a gift for X, Y, Z occasions, toss in some tidbits about the benefits of good gifting. Even modest gifts can lead to benefits like happier employees, higher retention, and increased productivity.

If your company’s email marketing squad is separate from your gifting team, work with them on setting up a regular cadence of gifting mentions in email, across your website, social, and more. Gifting doesn’t happen in a seasonal vacuum, and ignoring the gifting needs outside of Q4 could be leaving money on the table.

How to Turn Gift Recipients into First-time Gifters

Every gift sent creates two customers: the buyer and the recipient. Historically, brands have only had access to buyer data, which means they could never even reach out to recipients to try and convert them into making a purchase of their own.

With Zest, you now have access to recipient data along with all the ingredients needed that make each recipient a very warm lead. By the time you reach out to a recipient, all of the trust-building legwork has been done for you.

Recipe for a warm gifting lead

🤝 Ingredient #1: Trusted source
A recipient trusts the person who sent the gift, and that trust carries over to your product and brand. No ad can do that.
​

🗣️ Ingredient #2: Built-in social proof
Whether a recipient knows your brand or not, getting your product from someone they trust works like a personal 5-star review. That’s word of mouth at its best.

☝️ Ingredient #3: First-hand experience
Recipients hold, use, taste, or wear your product without you spending anything on ads or influencers. Now they can say, “I loved this, and I know it’ll make a great gift.”

😌 Ingredient #4: Memorable gifting experience
Digital gift messages, interactive unwrapping, shipping updates, thank-you notes: recipients have seen how delightful your gifting service is and they'll remember it for the long haul.

📧 Ingredient #5: Personalized push

The last ingredient is a personalized push from your brand that resurfaces all these good vibes and gives them a CTA direct to your gifting storefront.

🥧 Finished product: A verrry warm lead who loved the experience and will likely come to your store when they need a gift of their own. Your flywheel is officially underway.
​

Set up your recipient marketing opt-in

The next step for converting recipients into gifters is ensuring you maximize your opportunity to engage with them.

In other words, you need to ensure you have their permission to interact, which Zest has already baked into the e-gift recipient flow.

The recipient experience includes an optional checkbox that invites recipients to join your brand's email marketing list. This turns every gift into a potential new customer acquisition touchpoint.

  • The opt-in checkbox is enabled by default. You can disable it at the organization level or override it per Storefront in Storefront Settings.

  • You can customize the opt-in label text and the default checked/unchecked state in your seller settings.

  • Opt-in data flows back to your connected email platform (e.g., Klaviyo).

Heads up! To set up your recipient opt-in, check out this help article!

Maintain your brand's top-of-mind awareness with recipients

The top tactics we shared for staying wedged in the minds of gifters can also be applied to your gift recipients.

  • Inspire gifting around specific occasions.
    Occasion-anchored timing, like the examples mentioned earlier in this playbook, turns a vague “you could gift someday” into a concrete trigger — reminding recipients of an upcoming birthday, event, or milestone gives people a deadline and a specific person to buy for instead of asking them to gift in the abstract.
    ​

  • Lean into gifting reciprocity.
    Remind folks about the gift they received, how easy and delightful the process was, and the good vibes felt all around as a result. Wouldn’t it be nice to make someone else feel that good? Encouraging people to repay a kindness works better than generic marketing copy. Phrasing like “return the favor!” or “pay it forward” taps a feeling the recipient has already experienced rather than manufacturing a reason to buy out of thin air.
    ​

  • Incentivize recipients to send their first gift.
    Two-sided incentives (a discount for the recipient that also rewards the original sender, or vice versa) have a good history of converting intent into action — it reframes “buy something” as “get a deal while also doing something nice,” and rewards the existing relationship rather than treating the recipient as a cold lead.

Integrate With Klaviyo to Engage Corporate Gifters and Recipients All Year Long

Now that you've gotten permission to engage with gifters and recipients, and you have a better idea about what to say to them and when, let's look at the actual tool you need to make the magic happen.

Zest works seamlessly with Klaviyo, making it a powerful integration for scaling your gifting channel all year long with both past gifters and gifting hopefuls.

And just like when you integrate Klaviyo with your Shopify instance, Zest also automatically pushes transactional and behavioral data into the platform, so it’s ready for you to use when it’s time to build your next campaign.

Need to integrate with Klaviyo? See the step-by-step guide here.

As far as the information shared between these two platforms, Zest sends three marketing events from your corporate storefronts. All events start with the prefix

"Zest Platform - ".

Let's recap the exact event attributes you can leverage to send perfectly timed emails with a personalized touch.

Event 1: Zest Platform - Placed Gift Order

This fires when a gifter completes an order through your storefront.

Event attributes:

  • Number of Gifts

  • Digital Card Description

  • Zest Gift Order Number

  • Zest Gift Order ID

  • Zest Storefront

  • Zest Concierge Project

  • Selected Products

  • Value (order total, sent as the event's monetary value)

Event 2: Zest Platform - Accepted Gift

This fires when a gift recipient accepts their gift.

Event attributes:

  • Zest Gift Order Number

  • Zest Gift Order ID

  • Zest Gift Invite Number

  • Zest Gift Invite ID

  • From

  • Accepted Products

This event is a strong signal of a new potential customer who has already had a positive brand experience.

Event 3: Zest Platform - Active Lead

This fires when someone starts a gift order on your storefront but does not complete it — similar to an abandoned cart event.

Event attributes: This event includes the lead's email on their Klaviyo profile but does not include additional custom properties, like what was in their cart at the time they bounced.

9 Email Sequences to Set up in Klaviyo ASAP

1. Thank-you with intermittent nudges

  • Audience: Gifters

  • Trigger: Placed Gift Order

    • Day 2: A thank you note with early access to new or limited-edition gifts. Subject: “Thanks for gifting with us”

    • Day 60: “What’s your next occasion?” Point to non-holiday moments like new hires, work anniversaries, client thank yous and team wins, each linking to a curated gift.

    • Day 150: A mid-year occasion nudge.

    • Day 330: The anniversary reminder that personalizes with attributes Selected Products and Number of Gifts, like “Last year you sent 40 boxes of [product]. Ready to send the gift again?"

  • Why it works: It turns the first order date into a predictable yearly reminder with nudges in between.

2. Occasion follow-up based on the card message

  • Audience: Gifter

  • Trigger: Placed Gift Order, followed by a split on Digital Card Description

    • If the card description contains “welcome,” “onboard,” or “first day”: About 60 days later, send “More new hires on the horizon?” Link to welcome kit bundles.

    • If the card description contains “anniversary,” “congrats,” or “milestone”: About 90 days later, send “More wins worth celebrating.” Link to milestone gifts.

    • Everything else: Start a quarterly check-in flow with all gifters.

  • Why it works: The gifter has already told you their occasion, so the next email can be personalized to it.

    Heads up! For Klaviyo to pull in the events a digital card is for, you'll need to ensure your digital card descriptions are updated and align with the occasions you want to target, such as "work anniversary" or "new hire welcome."
    ​
    ​To learn more about card descriptions, check out this article.

3. VIP and big-program path

  • Audience: Gifter

  • Trigger: Placed Gift Order, filtered to Number of Gifts ≥ 25, Value ≥ your threshold, or orders where Zest Concierge Project is set

    • Immediately: Add them to a VIP list and update their profile.

    • Day 5: A plain-text email from a named person on your team offering a 15-minute gifting calendar planning call. Subject: “Planning more gifting? I can help”

    • Day 45: A VIP perk, such as volume pricing, custom bundles, or first access to new products.

  • Why it works: Bulk gifters are often running their company's gifting program, so give them a person to talk to instead of a newsletter.

4. Welcome and get-the-most-from-your-gift

  • Audience: Recipient

  • Trigger: Accepted Gift

    • Day 1: “[From] picked this out for you.” Add use or care tips based on Accepted Products attribute, and include a support link.

    • Day 7: Your brand story: who you are, how it’s made, and why people gift it.

  • Why it works: Recipients trust you because someone they know chose you. This builds on that trust before you ask for anything of them.
    ​
    ​

A simple Klaviyo flow that splits new or existing gifters and shares different messages with each.

5. Pay it forward

  • Audience: Recipient

  • Trigger: Accepted Gift

    • Day 14: “Remember how it felt when [From] sent you something great?” Link to your gifting storefront, with two or three easy, popular gifts highlighted n your email.

    • Day 30: A first-gift incentive offer, like “Give a gift, get $10 off for yourself.” Subject: “Your turn to make someone’s day”

  • Why it works: It uses reciprocity, a feeling the recipient has already had, instead of a generic “buy now.”

6. Bring it to work

  • Audience: Recipient

  • Trigger: Accepted Gift

    • Holiday timing: If the gift was accepted in Nov or Dec, wait until mid-February. That lines up with Employee Appreciation Day (first Friday in March).

    • Email 1: “Who handles gifting at your company?” Explain how easy corporate gifting is, and make the email easy to forward.

    • Email 2 (10 days later): The year-round occasion calendar, plus a link to your corporate storefront.

  • Why it works: Many recipients work at companies that send gifts. This turns one gift into a possible new corporate account.

7. Quick nudge plus social proof

  • Audience: Warm lead

  • Trigger: Active Lead

    • Immediately: “Still planning your gift?” Show your bestsellers and a “need help?” link.

    • Day 3: Two or three short testimonials from gifters and recipients. Subject: “What people say when they open one”

  • Why it works: It’s short, it doesn’t push, and the reviews ease last-minute doubts.

8. Choose your occasion

  • Audience: Warm lead

  • Trigger: Active Lead

    • Day 1: One email advertising gifts made for "New hires," "Client thank you," "Team milestone," and "Just because." Each button is a permalink that sends people to your storefront with the curated collection already in their cart.

  • Why it works: You don’t know what a lead had in their cart, so sharing a few concrete examples of curated collections could hit the mark or at least get them exploring your curated gifts.

9. New vs. returning gifter

  • Audience: Warm lead

  • Trigger: Active Lead, split on whether they’ve placed a gift order before

    • Returning gifters: “Welcome back. Want to reorder?” Point to the products they bought before and offer help.

    • First-timers: “Sending to a big group? No problem.” Explain bulk uploads, delivery tracking, e-gifting, and concierge help. Add a small first-order offer on day 4.

  • Why it works: Past gifters need a reminder, and first-timers often need help with logistics before they’ll buy.

Rule of thumb: We recommend keeping flows relatively simple — one trigger event and one or two emails within a flow is typically enough to start, especially if you’re sending emails with gift guides or mentions in addition to triggered sequences. Ramp up once you feel comfortable doing so and have insight into messaging that resonates.
​
Because Zest handles all transactional gifting emails on the corporate side, you don't need to build flows for order confirmations, gift delivery notifications, or shipping updates.

Start Your Strategy in January

Don’t let your gifting insights go to waste in the year ahead. There are so many possibilities when it comes to engaging people who’ve sent or received gifts from your brand, the only thing you have to do is start somewhere. If you're not sure where to begin, start small with the checklist below and expand your tactics as you're able.

Your January checklist

☑ Build segments in Klaviyo of everyone who placed or accepted a gift in Q4, and send them one-time catch-up emails

☑ Confirm the recipient opt-in is true

☑ Launch three starter flows (we recommend starting 1, 5 and 7 from above)

☑ Add a gifting blurb to every email

And remember: You’re in total control of your cadence and messaging, but this is one place where even a little effort can go a long way in building up your year-round gifting program. Now, go get those gifters!

Did this answer your question?